Keeping records by hand? Really?
02/06/2012
I volunteer for a local non-profit that has raised nearly $1 million in the past three years. One of my responsibilities is to check the mail a few times a week and write acknowledgement letters for donations before turning the proceeds over to our treasurer for processing and deposit.
Recently, I received a frantic email from a local business owner stating that he had mistakenly mailed us a check that was meant for his commercial landlord. He was alerted to this after receiving our acknowledgement letter. He was emailing us to chastise us for cashing a check that was clearly meant for someone else.
Fortunately, our treasurer keeps very good records, including scanning each check we receive. A third volunteer enters the information into a comprehensive spreadsheet. We keep these duplicate records because we feel it’s particularly important that we are transparent and absolutely correct in handling these very generous donations. In several cases, our back-up system has saved us much time and effort, as well as confusion, so we are glad we do it.
So, I was able to go back to the scanned document as well as the spreadsheet to find this particular check. While the owner had claimed that the check was clearly made out to the landlord, it was not. It was clearly made out to our non-profit organization. The confusion resulted from the fact that both the landlord’s company and our organization share the first two words in our respective names, and in one of those “brain blips” that we all have, the check writer had filled it out incorrectly (by hand). What was really amazing is that the check writer had then mailed the check to our post office box, so the error was repeated in addressing the envelope.
The business owner really took us to task over what was really his mistake. Once we could demonstrate that the error was on his end, he backed off and apologized profusely. We returned the check and adjusted our records. It was the first incident of that kind we have had, and I hope it’s the last.
However, it really emphasized to me the dangerous ramifications of doing sloppy work. Someone – either the business owner or his office staff – made the check out in error and then mailed it in error as well. We did the right thing by returning the check, but others might not have. This kind of mistake could have easily cost this business dearly, and it could have been avoided.
- Use technology. An automated accounting program such as Quickbooks would have caught this error by requiring the check writer to enter new vendor information. Sitting and writing checks by hand is an excellent way to let your mind’s wanderings cause mistakes. An automated program would also have kept an electronic record so the business owner could have seen where the error was made.
- Add some checks and balances. Pardon the pun, but if you or one of your employees is the only one reviewing payables, you need to broaden your reach. We all make mistakes, and another set of eyes on your books and bills will help minimize those. Even someone part time just to double-check entries can help.
- Review your accounts frequently. Don’t simply rely on employees to monitor your costs and revenue. You should peruse the payables and receivables several times each month to not only manage cash flow, but also to provide another back-up review. You may start to see trends or, conversely, stand-out entries that may point to some problems or errors in the record-keeping.
Any of these simple strategies likely would have helped our local business owner avoid the error, and the embarrassment he created for himself when he realized that he was the party at fault.
As the saying goes, “No harm, no foul.”
But the next folks might not be so understanding.

